I was looking through the nominations for the 2027 Grammy Awards when I got especially interested in one category. This year's nominees for Best Alternative Music Album include Alabama Shakes, Phoebe Bridgers, Charli xcx, Geese, Gorillaz, and Rosalía. I tried to imagine what a playlist consisting exclusively of these artists would sound like, and I'm not entirely sure I would be able to identify a common genre without already knowing what the playlist was called.
Which made me wonder what we actually mean when we describe music as alternative. Are we talking about the way it sounds, the audience it attracts, the artist's approach to making music, or simply the fact that we don't quite know where else to put it?
The Recording Academy itself offers a somewhat open-ended definition. It describes alternative music in terms of progression and innovation, acknowledging that the category can include recordings that don't fit into other established genres. What's interesting about that definition is that it tells us relatively little about what alternative music actually sounds like. Unlike categories that are at least partly defined by recognizable musical characteristics, alternative seems to be defined by its relationship with other music.
And that relationship has changed quite a bit. Alternative rock emerged from underground music communities in the 1970s and 1980s, developing around independent record labels, college radio stations, smaller venues, and the cultural aftermath of punk. What connected many of these artists wasn't necessarily a particular sound, but the fact that they existed outside the dominant structures of commercial rock music. Bands could sound completely different from one another and still belong to a similar musical culture because of how and where their music circulated.
By the early 1990s, however, the distinction was already becoming complicated. Nirvana's Nevermind reached the top of the Billboard 200, R.E.M. became an internationally successful band, and the sounds associated with underground rock became commercially desirable. The music that had been positioned as an alternative to the mainstream was becoming a significant part of it.
Interestingly, the Grammys introduced their alternative music category in 1991, the same year Nevermind was released. Its first winner was Sinéad O'Connor for I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got, an album containing one of the biggest pop hits of its time, "Nothing Compares 2 U." The other nominees included Kate Bush, Laurie Anderson, the Replacements, and World Party. Even then, there was considerable musical variation within the category, and commercial success clearly didn't disqualify an artist from being considered alternative.
Looking through its previous winners makes that even more apparent. Radiohead won for Kid A, Coldplay won consecutive awards for Parachutes and A Rush of Blood to the Head, and Gnarls Barkley won for St. Elsewhere. More recently, the category has recognized Fiona Apple, St. Vincent, Vampire Weekend, and the Cure. There are overlapping influences between some of these artists, but trying to identify a consistent musical characteristic that connects all of them becomes increasingly difficult.
There's actually an interesting sociological explanation for why this happens. In a 2008 study published in the American Sociological Review, Jennifer C. Lena and Richard A. Peterson examined the development of 60 American musical genres. Rather than categorizing genres exclusively through their musical characteristics, they looked at the social, organizational, and cultural structures surrounding them. Their research identified four different types of genre organization: avant-garde, scene-based, industry-based, and traditionalist.
What I find interesting about their research is that it demonstrates how the nature of a genre can change as the communities and institutions surrounding it change. Music that initially develops within a small experimental community can eventually become an established scene, attract commercial attention, and acquire an entirely different cultural position from the one it originally occupied.
This is especially relevant to alternative because its identity was historically so dependent on its position outside mainstream culture. Once the music industry began actively marketing that position, being alternative became something that could be commercially produced and distributed. An artist no longer necessarily had to operate outside the mainstream to occupy a cultural space associated with it.
I think Charli xcx is an interesting contemporary example of this. Her work has long drawn from experimental electronic music, underground club culture, and the more unconventional possibilities of pop production. Yet Brat became one of the most recognizable cultural phenomena of 2024, reaching audiences well beyond the communities that had been following her work for years. It would be difficult to argue that her music wasn't part of mainstream popular culture at that point, but its commercial success didn't erase the musical influences or creative approaches that made it distinctive in the first place.
And now, with Music, Fashion, Film nominated for Best Alternative Music Album, we're seeing how an artist can move between different institutional definitions without necessarily abandoning the creative identity that connects those projects.
Rosalía's nomination for LUX (Complete Works) raises a slightly different question. Her work has moved between flamenco, reggaeton, electronic production, pop, and classical influences throughout her career. On LUX, the orchestral arrangements, multilingual performances, and religious imagery create a musical world that's difficult to describe through any one of those traditions. The album is also nominated for Album of the Year, and Rosalía has received nominations across pop, alternative, Latin, and global music categories this year.
I find those distinctions interesting because none of them necessarily contradict one another. They're identifying different aspects of the same artist's work. But it does make me wonder whether we're categorizing music according to its musical characteristics, its cultural origins, or the particular way the industry has learned to understand the artist making it.
It's also worth considering how differently listeners encounter genres today. When radio stations and record stores were among the primary ways of discovering music, genre distinctions had a fairly obvious practical function. They helped determine which station might play a recording, where an album would be placed in a store, and which publications might cover it. Discovering music often involved entering spaces that were already organized around particular genres.
Streaming hasn't eliminated those distinctions, but it has changed how visible they are to listeners. A playlist might be organized around a mood, an activity, a particular aesthetic, or a combination of artists whose music shares relatively few traditional genre characteristics. Someone listening to a playlist called "late night drive" probably isn't concerned with whether the next song is classified as alternative R&B, indie rock, or electronic pop, as long as it makes sense within the experience they're looking for.
That doesn't mean we've entered a genreless era, though. Digital music platforms still rely heavily on classification to organize and recommend recordings. Labels need to position releases, publicists need to identify relevant audiences, and award institutions need categories in which to recognize music. I think the tension we're seeing is partly a result of those systems trying to accommodate artists whose work moves between the very distinctions they're built around.
There's another complication with alternative specifically. Unlike most genre labels, being described as alternative can carry an implication about the artistic value of the music itself. It can suggest that something is more experimental, independent-minded, or creatively ambitious than its mainstream counterparts. We don't always use the word as a neutral description of sound.
I've noticed how casually people make distinctions between pop and alternative, as though one is primarily concerned with commercial appeal while the other is concerned with artistic expression. But that distinction overlooks how much experimentation has historically happened within pop music and how commercially successful alternative music can be. Making something accessible doesn't necessarily make it less innovative, just as making something difficult to categorize doesn't automatically make it more interesting.
There's also a risk in assuming that genre distinctions are no longer important simply because artists are crossing them. Studying ethnomusicology has made me aware of how genres carry histories that extend beyond their sonic characteristics. They're connected to particular communities, geographical locations, social experiences, and ways of understanding music. Describing everything as genreless might sound liberating, but it can also make it easier to overlook the traditions that artists are drawing from.
Rosalía's engagement with flamenco, for example, becomes considerably more interesting when we understand something about flamenco as a musical and cultural tradition. Categorizing her work as alternative might help accommodate its stylistic range, but it doesn't necessarily tell us much about the individual influences that make that range meaningful.
And perhaps that's what makes this year's Grammy category so interesting. Geese's approach to rock, Rosalía's orchestral experimentation, Charli xcx's electronic influences, and Gorillaz's longstanding practice of bringing different musical worlds together all represent different relationships with existing genre conventions. They don't have to sound alike to share an interest in exploring what their respective musical traditions can accommodate.
But that makes alternative a rather unusual category. While other genres generally give artists a set of conventions to work within, alternative seems to give artists room to work against conventions that may have very little to do with one another.
Maybe we've reached a point where alternative tells us less about where an artist exists within the music industry and more about how they approach the music they're making. And perhaps the most interesting thing about the Grammy category isn't that it brings together artists who sound so different, but that it asks us to recognize what they're doing creatively without necessarily agreeing on what kind of music they're making.
There's something ironic about the music industry's attempt to categorize music that resists categorization. But maybe the fact that this year's nominees are so difficult to group together tells us more about alternative music than any definition could.